Centrifugal dust separatorA conventional cyclone separator needs a fair amount of vertical height to allow the dust to drop down the cone.
An alternative form of cyclone is what is known as a " Thien-baffle". In a Thien-baffle, the air spirals in a flat shape from the edge to the center, whereas in a cyclone it moves in more of a helical pattern down the cone and then back up the middle.
The advantage of a Thien-baffle is that it uses up very little vertical height.
For the separator for my small dust extractor, I figured I'd combine elements of both. The top of the separator is like a traditional cyclone, but instead of having a tapered cone towards the bottom, I'd just end it with a Thien-baffle like disk.
I needed to make a cylindrical enclosure for my separator. I first considered making this out of a plastic bucket, but attaching parts to a cut up plastic bucket would introduce challenges of its own. So I made it out of wood instead.
I started with an arc shaped template and used that to mark a series of arc outlines on a thick piece of hardwood. I then cut these out on the bandsaw.
I added a ledge of plywood to help keep the dust bucket aligned on the bottom.
With the separator ahead of the fan, the separator will always have a slight vacuum in it. With air leaking in instead of out, I don't have to worry about dust getting out of the bucket. So I don't need a completely airtight seal.
I also added a "vane" to the bottom of my separator to keep the air in the bucket from spinning too much, but with my bucket already mounted close to the floor on the finished unit, that vane made it difficult to get the bucket in and out, so I removed it later.
In a typical Thien-baffle, the air is injected using a pipe elbow. But I didn't want the back of the elbow getting in the way of the air circling around the chamber, so I made a sort of "injector nozzle" to shoot the air in from the edge.
I tapered this injector a little to give the air a bit of extra speed as it enters the separator. I figured, compared to the air resistance of the corrugated hose, this slight contraction of the air stream shouldn't make that big a difference in terms of air resistance.
Looking into the end of the injector nozzle. I tried to make sure the nozzle was fairly smooth the way it led to the narrower slot at the end (this view makes the slot look narrower than it really is).
It worked well enough, although I was getting some dust in the filter. The separator wasn't perfect with this test, but it worked.
For another test, I sucked the contents of my bandsaw sawdust drawer through as fast as possible. After finishing, I could see that dust was still flowing into the collection bucket. Apparently, the dust had started to pile up on top of the baffle in the cyclone. Checking the filter, it was completely caked with dust!
With the filter so caked with dust, I was wondering about the effectiveness of my separator. But with further experimentation, I realized that I just way overloaded the cyclone it and effectively "stalled" the circulating air flow. With much dust and not enough air, dust started to pile up on top of the baffle, which further reduced air circulation.
Trolling around YouTube, I found some interesting related videos:
Gas cyclone separator (effect of solid flow rate)
This video first shows the cyclone with light load, followed by a heavy load. Again, you can see circulation slowing down. Slower circulation means less centrifugal force, and therefore less effective particle separation.
Though the furnace filter was meant to be disposable, I cleaned it out with an air compressor. I had my other dust extractor running to catch all the dust I'm blowing out. I learned not to get too close to the filter itself with my air nozzle. 100 PSI air is apparently enough to blow holes in a furnace filter. I fixed the holes with a bit of glue.
.. which attaches to the bottom of the filter box. I also added a few pieces to hold the separator more firmly to the filter box. The filter box, being the largest part of the dust extractor, essentially became the "chassis" for the whole thing.
It won't move as much air as good size shop vac, but it's also much quieter and consumes much less power. If I was building it again, I'd look for a slightly bigger motor, maybe 1/2 HP.