Making a curvy board - an experiment with free-form bent lamination
My sister saw this curvy board for sale on Etsy, for $120. She wanted to know if it was hard to make one of these. That is to say, she thought it would be a good gift for her kids if I could figure out how to make one.
That got me thinking. My first thought was to maybe make it segmented, with the individual pieces finger joined with my screw advance box joint jig. But then I figured a bent lamination from thin pieces of plywood would be less work.
A big part of a project like that is building the bending form, but when making just one of these, the bending form would involve more work and material than the project itself. So my challenge was to try to make one without making a bending form. I had experimented with semi-free-form bending before with this weaving frame and my pirate sword, but never at this scale.
The first step was to work out the shape. I used one of my tape measures as a compass to draw lines of different radii to figure out what sort of curve I wanted (the pencil lines are a bit hard to see in the photo - click photo to enlarge). This project was very much experimental, so no CAD here!
I had it cut in half at the store so I could get it in my car. I then cut each half into three strips 25 cm wide.
The cargo strap doesn't apply any leverage at the ends, so the ends of the boards, with much less bending moment on them, are relatively straight. I didn't find that curve very satisfying.
I'm using a rubber spatula to spread the glue. This worked out ok enough, but if I was doing it again, I'd probably use a big rubber squeegee. Time is of the essence for a large glue-up like that, and a wide squeegee would be faster.
This took far too long. If I was doing it again, I would have all my C-clamps already screwed to the right opening. Also, if I had clamping cauls that my clamps could somehow hook to, that would cut down on fiddling with them.
I'm not sure if the clamping cauls apply much pressure in the middle. Lightly curved clamping cauls would help a lot too.
Mind you, I'm even more skeptical of the typical two-sided bending forms that people make. If the bending form is rigid on both sides, there's no guarantee that it applies even pressure across the whole workpiece.
At any rate, I decided that this was successful enough to continue with the experiment.
Applying glue again. Foolishly, I started by applying glue to the outside of the already built shape. By the time I finished applying glue to the other five surfaces, that first surface already started to dry, so I had to add a second coat of glue.
I hadn't really thought this through that much. For the first three layers, I only had four surfaces to apply glue to, but to add three layers meant applying glue to six surfaces. A faster method of applying glue, like a squeegee would certainly have helped! A bigger glue container would also have helped - I had to refill partway thru the glue-up.
This straightened out the curve a bit more. But I figured this would actually help me in the end.
Things were made more complicated by the fact that the sandwich was now too thick for my blocks to hook over the ends. So that involved more delays unscrewing the blocks and screwing them back together with a slight gap in them.
There are so many things I could do better if I was doing it again! Much learned!
With some gaps still visible at the edges of the wood, it was time to apply clamps
again. Lots of clamps!
I cut the board to its final length. My laminates were 1.5 meters (60") long, but that's a bit unwieldy. The curvy board that you can buy is only 34" (86 cm) long. I left mine at about 1.2 meters long.
Trimming the edges. My first thought was to do that on the jointer, a bit like I did for my crokinole board frame or the weaving frame, but since I discovered that plywood damages jointer knives I decided to trim it on the table saw instead.
I'm sure the safety trolls will have something to say about that: "What an idiot, that will cause kickback, guaranteed", but no such thing happened. The risk of kickback is actually much smaller with heavier workpieces, and with me on the outfeed side of the saw and holding the stock far from the blade, kickback would have mostly damaged the workpiece or my saw, but not me.
Note also that I left my crosscut sled on the left side. I figured if something did go wrong, it would just slam up against that. With me only trimming 2 mm off the board, it didn't get in the way.
Next rounding the edges. I'm using my older router lift, just because it's attached to my bigger saw so I have a bigger table to work with.
Unfortunately, there was some imperfect gluing of the laminations, as you can see in this photo (click photo to enlarge). Aside from taking too long to apply glue and clamp, and having my glue get too dry, I should have also applied more glue. But even so, I used up about 300 milliters (10 oz) of glue.
So I decided to shoot the intro scene for my video before putting much stress on the board. I would have been ok with it exploding into a million pieces. This experiment was interesting enough even if it was a failure.
But surprisingly, standing on it, even bouncing up and down a bit, it held my weight!
Trying to push the lamination straight is the worst thing you can do to it. If you look at the previous example with the book, if increasing curvature pushes the laminates together, trying to straighten the curve really pulls them apart!
I was able to slip a shim about 5 cm into the biggest gap that opened up, so I put lots of glue on the cracks and worked it in with a shim as best as I could, then clamped the gap together. I also shortened the board by about 10 cm after that, so there would be less length to get leverage on.
It would be fun to create a bending form to do one of these "properly". I think the best way would be to have convex cylindrical mold, and then push the laminates onto the mold by having some straps pulled very tightly around the curved mold. That would ensure even pressure. And if I combined that with a better method of applying glue to the layers, making a curvy board would be a snap!
And just what does one use a curvy board for? Well, it's a teeter totter, a rocking cradle, a bridge, a ramp for jumping toy cars, a roof beam for a fort made of couch cushions, and whatever comes to mind.
But in a child's world dominated by TV, video games and action figures, a kid might not know what to do with it. Fortunately, my sister is a bit more selective about what to entertain her kids with.
More kid's toy creations:
The Hui game