The physics of bandsaw resawingThis article also available in Italian
I occasionally get emails from people who have trouble with resawing lumber
on their bandsaw.
To illustrate some of the concepts, I made a simple "model" of a bandsaw blade cutting through wood. I used sawdust on the table to model the board being cut. Each tooth, as it passes through the board, cuts out some wood chips, and carries them out of the cut.
But if we cut through much thicker stock, what works for a normal board no longer works. With a really deep cut, there just isn't enough room between the teeth to carry away all the sawdust produced by each tooth on the way through. Once the space between the teeth is full, some of the sawdust gets squeezed into the kerf next to the blade, which then causes more friction. The sawdust may be forced more to one side than the other, which can lead to the blade wandering.
The solution, it would seem, is to cut slower. But as the blade gets slightly dull, the tip of each tooth becomes slightly rounded instead of a perfect point. When the tooth isn't pushed into the wood fast enough, that round causes the tooth to just rub on the edge of the cut instead of biting into the wood. So really slow feed rates only work when the blade is very sharp.
A solution to this problem is to use a blade with fewer teeth on it. This allows for more room between the teeth for the sawdust. But it also means that for the same bite of each tooth, less power, and less feed pressure pushing the wood against the blade is needed.
But for very deep cuts, such as when resawing wood that is 30 cm (12") wide, even with a 2 TPI (tooth per inch) blade, there are 24 teeth in the wood at the same time.
Those 24 teeth add up to quite a lot of power and feed pressure.
In this "model", the strip of cardboard is the blade, and I'm pushing against it with a steel ruler. Under pressure, the strip of cardboard has a tendency to buckle away from the force. This starts with the front edge of the cardboard buckling sideways.
This sideways buckling can be countered by pulling both ends of the cardboard strip so it's really right -- essentially, more blade tension. But even with the blade under tension, once the feed pressure exceeds a certain amount, (what is referred to as the "beam strength" of the blade), it will still want to buckle sideways.
Think of the blade like an upright "beam" supported by the upper and lower blade guides, and the wood pushing against it. With a beam, this push causes a bending moment, which causes compression along the edge we are pushing against, and tension along the opposite edge. If the beam consists of just a thin strip of metal, like a bandsaw blade, compression will cause that side to buckle. What holds the blade straight is tension, but once the blade's tension is canceled out by the compression from the beam effect, there is very little to hold that edge straight. Once the front edge is under pressure, it will start to buckle by twisting away from the force.
Applying more down force on the saw makes it worse. But adding more tension to the blade make this happen much less.
Wider blades help in this regard. For the same amount of tension, a blade twice as wide will have twice as much beam strength. But at the same time, wider blades can take more tension. At left - a 1/4" wide 10 TPI blade, a 1/2" wide 4 TPI blade, and a 3/4" (19 mm) wide 2 TPI blade.
Some people prefer really wide blades for resawing, but for my purposes, 3/4" has always been wide enough. Even 1/2" wide blades have enough beam strength for resawing if sufficiently tensioned. The 3/4" wide blade on the right is the one I used for cutting up a log. Though I had previously cut up a short log with just a 1/2" 3 TPI blade. With just a 1 HP motor on the saw, but a very sturdy tensioning mechanism, lack of motor power was a bigger limitation than beam strength of the blade.
If you find that your blade has gotten too dull to resaw, that doesn't mean the blade is too dull for other work. Once the blade is too dull to cut through 30 cm (12") of material, it will still cut through 15 cm (6") of material just fine. You will have an easier time resawing if you cut your boards to the width you need them before resawing.
Metal fatigueYou may worry about damaging the blade from over-tensioning, but it's just about impossible to over-tension a 1/2" blade with most bandsaws. You will damage the saw before you damage the blade. But too little tension can also lead to blade breakage, as the blade maybe forced around some tight bends near the blade guides. Tight bends cause stress and metal fatigue, leading to cracking between the teeth and blade breakage. If you see cracks in multiple places on your blades, that's metal fatigue.
Too heavy a blade around too small a wheel will cause the blade to fail from prematurely from metal fatigue. If you run a blade meant for a portable sawmill around 14" (35 cm) wheels or smaller, don't expect it to last very long. I'm pushing the limits with my 14" bandsaw/sawmill, but I don't use sawmill blades on it either.
On that topic this guys YouTube video is interesting. He's using a sawmill blade on 14" wheels. Bound to fail eventually. A blade guard wouldn't hurt either!
"Low tension" bladesThere are companies that sell so called "low tension blades". I don't understand what the magic of these blades is supposed to be. Any metal that is mostly iron will have nearly the same Young's modulus (resistance to elastic deformation), and the same physics applies. I'm pretty sure the whole low tension thing is just a bunch of marketing mumbo jumbo. That said, nothing wrong with buying a low tension blade, just make sure you put enough tension on it. Remember, except for the narrowest blades, the blade can withstand more tension than your saw can give it!
Chatter and bounce with hook tooth blades and very hard woods
When I got my 26" bandsaw built far enough that I could try some resawing with it, I cut up a big piece of ironwood (American hophornbeam). I didn't get far into it when the blade snagged on the wood and came off the saw! Fortunately without damaging anything. I had the blade tension too low, so once it snagged, it slipped on the wheels, and that caused it to slide off the wheels. I added more tension and cut again.
But I'd still got these occasional loud "bang" sounds where the blade got snagged for a fraction of a millisecond and immediately tore itself loose. Each time, you could see all the wood and the sawdust on the table bounce, as if I hit a hammer down on the piece of wood.
I spent some time investigating this. The problem only occurred with very hard woods like the ironwood or some hard maple (sugar maple). Softer woods cut fairly smoothly.
The blade I was using was a very sharp hook toothed blade, and I believe what is happening is that the hook sometimes really grabs onto the wood and pulls the blade deeper into the wood. With softer woods, the fibers just bend out of the way a bit so the teeth don't hook onto the blade, but with very hard woods, the fibers don't yield, so the teeth can really hook on.
I assume this would be less of a problem for hook tooth blades on a sawmill because logs are milled before drying, and wood is softer before drying.
The problem is made less bad if the grain of the wood points down slightly towards the teeth, so the teeth have less to hook on to. Also, I wasn't getting this with a different blade that didn't have as much of a hook to it.
Wooden bandsaw riser block (2017)
Homemade bandsaw/sawmill (2011)
Why bandsaw blades
Bandsaw on a dolly sawmill (2017)
20" bandsaw build (2016)
More about bandsaws