Box dust collector
I was experimenting with using a motor from a dishwasher to make a blower for another mini dust collector. The motor was more powerful than the furnace exhaust blower motors I used here, so I could build a bigger blower with more suction.
The first blower I built didn't use all the available power of the motor, so I built a slightly bigger one. I made a bigger impeller, using the same method as this one. But this time I designed the housing in CAD. That way I could print out templates for the spiral housing, which made making the housing much quicker if not counting design time.
The nice thing about cutting out the segments like this was that I could sand them one at a time on my belt sander. I don't have a spindle sander.
Testing it, the motor consumed 222 watts with air free flowing. That's more than its rating, so it was overloaded. But if I constricted the air flow, the motor's power consumption dropped below its rating and RPM was above, so it was no longer overloaded.
I designed the spiral with a fairly generous exit path, but if I can't put that much air through it because of motor power limits, I might as well tighten up the spiral so it's closer to circular. This makes the blower slightly smaller.
The motor was still overloaded with free air flow, but if it has to pull air through a dust collector with hoses and filters, air flow will be more restricted, and hopefully the motor won't be overloaded.
My initial idea had been to just mount the blower onto a cardboard box with a filter in it for a test. But at 175 mm static suction, I would have had to reinforce the cardboard box. And then there is the question of how to open the box to look inside and also seal it. And the box wasn't quite the right size for my filter. So I figured it would be simpler to just make a wooden box.
I used some scraps of plywood from the garbage, and two cabinet doors from a yard sale. Here I'm jigging things up for screwing the pieces together. (The door that's horizontal is just there to help jig things up temporarily)
Screwing the top plywood onto the doors. The plywood only overlaps the doors by 8 mm. Ideally, that plywood would have been wider, but this piece was just about the right size. In fact, cutting all the pieces to size for the box, I ended up with almost no scraps at all.
At right, screwing on what will be the "back" of the box.
I glued most of the joints, so I cut away the melamine coating along the edges where it joins with the kitchen cabinet doors.
The glue's primary function here is to act as a sealant.
The filters I'm using are designed for use in a furnace. Furnace blowers produce about a tenth of the static suction as my blower, so I made a lattice to help support the filter against the pressure (for when the filter becomes very caked with dust).
I sanded the ends of some pieces of wood round and pounded them into angled holes on bigger pieces of wood.
I cut a series of notches into a piece of wood, then cut that into two strips. These strips fit around the ends of the brackets I just put into the box, and screw into the sides to hold the brackets in place.
In these photos, the box is upside down from how it will be in the dust collector.
My initial idea was one tall window so I could better see how high the dust was in the box, but then decided to make it two square holes instead, so I wouldn't be weakening the lid as much.
I didn't have an appropriate flange so I just put a 4" ducting elbow in the hole and screwed it on from the inside. I put some duct tape around it to help seal it.
Then installing the first filter. I'm using masking tape to seal into the box. I had some problems with filter blow-by on my mini dust collector, so I figured tape should solve that. I don't anticipate changing the filters that often, and if I do, the tape is a small cost compared to the filter.
This filter is more of a back-up for the other filters. Furnace filters, when not caked with dust, have very little air resistance, so it's not doing any harm.
I wanted some sort of compressible seal for the main lid. Wood chips really stick to felt, so I figured I'd try some strips of corrugated cardboard. I'm not sure how that will hold up over time as the lid is removed from time to time.
The lid just screws onto the box with wood screws. The screw holes may wear out eventually from opening and closing the box, at which point I might switch to gluing some threaded rod into the box and using wing nuts or something like that.
But right now, I'm not sure how practical this thing is, and wood screws are quick and don't preclude using a better solution later.
I figured a rather overloading test for this set-up was to hook it up to my Dewalt 735 thickness planer. The blower on this planer blows so much air out that it overwhelms a lot of dust collectors.
I hooked it up with some cheap dryer hose. Not the best hose for this job, but it has the advantage that you can see if the hose has positive or negative pressure in it.
But as soon as I ran a board through the planer, it slowed it down enough that its internal blower put out less air, and the hose started shrinking again. So while planing, the dust collector was barely keeping up.
The planer also didn't drop a lot of chips on the table. When there isn't enough air flow, a lot of shavings end up falling onto the table.
I checked the air with my Dylos particle counter. It showed that some of the very fine dust was making it through the filters. I expect this to improve as the filters become caked with dust (a layer of fine dust is an excellent filter). Though once it's caked with dust, air flow will be reduced and might not be enough for the planer.
At any rate, I think this is a useful dust collector. And with a motor that is at most 1/8 hp, it's doing pretty good. I would say, performance is very comparable to my cheap dust collector. Static suction is about the same, and air flow on that unit is not that great now that the filter bag is caked with dust.
I may end up making a mount for a thickness planer to go on top of this box, probably my cheap one (this one), which doesn't need quite as much air flow.
Two weeks later, particle counts when using it were down substantially, so the filters were sufficiently caked with dust. The sawdust itself actually helps to filter (this is called "Seasoning" the filter).
Power consumption also dropped to 1.74 amperes (or about 200 watts), which tells me air flow is down a little from extra air resistance in the filter.
It still works ok with my thickness planer and also sucks all the shavings out of my jointer. So overall, I'll call this experiment a success. Though if I was building it again, I'd try to find a slightly bigger motor. If you want to build one, use a filter with wide pleats. Tightly spaced pleats end up getting the space between the pleats filled with dust, causing unnecessary air resistance.
Update 2018(1 year after I built it)
The masking tape I used to hold up the filter really did not hold up. I replaced it with duct tape, but that also was unable to hold up the filters over time. I made a video about that. I screwed some pieces of wood in to actually hold the filter (and tape) in place.
After moving to the country, set this dust collector hooked up permanently to my homemade jointer, while using my big old dust "Startrite" collector for the planer.
The capacity is big enough, though after making lots of baseboards I had to empty it eventually. Emptying it is kind of annoying with all the screws that need to come out, but it's something I have really only had to do once so far (not counting the two times I had it open to fix the tape not holding problems). Even with all the screws, emptying it is comparable in annoyance to emptying and reattaching the bag on one of these.
So far I quite like this concept of dust collector, my next iteration of it is the dust collector for my table saw. This one is much easier to empty.
Random dust collection updates (video only)
Back to my Woodworking website